Valley resident Ashley Molina held her breath and closed her
eyes before diving into the raw sewage. Just a few months ago
Ashley was sitting on her couch, wondering why so many Fear
Factor contestants wimp out when faced with stunts. Now she
knows; it's the smell.
But Ashley and her husband Dean braved the stench and won the
$1 million grand prize on NBC's Fear Factor Couples. "We really
didn't even watch reality TV that much before being on a show
ourselves," says Dean.
That puts Dean and Ashley in the minority of reality TV viewers,
as statistics and real-life stories point to an increasing trend
of fanaticism in reality TV viewers. A new breed of reality
TV fans fosters life-like relationships with the real-life contestants
of the shows.
And the audience numbers seem to be increasing. Now in its tenth
season, CBS's Survivor lured a record-setting 24 million Americans
to its mid-February premier.
And while reality TV draws millions from its ideal demographic,
females age 18 to 34, the "what will they do" scenarios are
drawing in all sorts of viewers.
"Reality TV is the only kind of TV I watch. Not too many sitcoms
grab my attention," says 25-year-old Sean Samuel, a commercial
real estate broker. In a given week Samuel works about 50 hours
in the office, and spends at least nine hours watching reality
TV.
"I find time," Samuel says of his busy schedule. One co-worker
even refers to him as "Reality Check."
For reasons sociological, spiritual or primordial, humans are
drawn to other humans more than anything else. So it only makes
sense that the most popular TV shows would be all about live
and real people.
"You need TiVo or something to watch a lot if you're working.
I probably have four or five shows going at a time," adds Samuel.
Asked to list the shows, he begins naming and quickly revises
the count. "Maybe it's more like eight, nine or ten shows a
week," he says, adding that, "With proper time management and
an efficient TV recording device you can really get in a lot
of reality TV time."
Samuel isn't alone. A weekday afternoon visit to a reality TV
chat site reveals 203 live members chatting about the outcome
of The Bachelorette.
"I'm kind of embarrassed to admit it, but I am a reality TV
nut!" writes one reality TV aficionado. "I think I have watched
every reality show!"
Like Samuel, an analytical real estate broker at a reputable
firm, reality TV enthusiasts often defy stereotypes. Some are
outspoken while others remain embarrassed by the draw of the
shows, and refer to themselves as "closet reality fans."
"I don't tell people," says Tracey Andrews, a newspaper distribution
manager for an award-winning monthly Valley features publication.
As much as Samuel enjoys watching reality TV, he's never considered
going on a show himself. "I like watching how dumb people can
be sometimes. I don't want to go on there and be that person.
"But for some reason the shows really like casting in Scottsdale,
especially the dating shows," Samuels says. "They asked my girlfriend
if she'd go on The Bachelor. Thankfully she said no," he said.
Reality TV does exhibit an affinity for Valley contestants,
from Dean and Ashley on Fear Factor to Jon Buehler, who earned
second place on the grueling Amazing Race. And more recently
the Gilbert family whose house was transformed into a $500,000
dream home for the popular Extreme Makeover: Home Edition series.
Speaking of makeover, the Valley also lays claim to the Phoenix
twins who underwent about $25,000 worth of cosmetic surgery
to look like Brad Pitt for MTV's I Want a Famous Face.
Thanks to TiVo, reality TV rarely poses a serious priority conflict
for reality TV lovers like Samuel. Though he does say his parents,
also reality TV fans, would probably understand if a culminating
show aired during one of their birthday parties.
The most common conflict Samuel's reality passion incurs is
with his girlfriend. "She asks me to TiVo shows that aren't
things I like to watch, Desperate Housewives and The OC, but
sometimes I unintentionally, intentionally record my shows instead
of hers."
While Samuel doesn't necessarily consider himself an addict,
his passion for reality TV often surprises his friends and even
himself. "When anybody brings up any show any time, I know what's
going on with it," he says.
"I don't waste a minute of time when I could be watching; when
it's time to watch TV it's all filled in with shows."
So what motivates this kind of commitment? Samuel says reality
TV is perhaps the most human form of entertainment. "I love
to people watch," he explains. "When I go to Disneyland I almost
enjoy standing in lines more than the ride, looking at funny
people, how people interact. In reality TV they're put in situations
they know will be entertaining."
The Molinas agree. Dean says that Americans prefer reality TV
because viewers can personally relate to the contestants. "That's
kind of like me or my friend, you say while watching. That's
a little different from watching Brad Pitt or Jennifer Aniston."
Good or bad, reality shows appear to be here to stay, and it
may just be a matter of time before we all know someone who
has participated on one.