 Heightened
Danger
Raised trucks raising Concerns
- John Dickerson
Andrez Franco held the blue steering wheel of his Ford Tempo as
he drove his usual route home from work. It had been a long shift
washing dishes at a busy restaurant. He and his four passengers
were looking forward to getting home.
The conversation in Franco's vehicle carried on normally when he
stopped his gold-colored car at the traffic light near Scottsdale
Road and Cheney.
Whether Franco ever saw it coming is impossible to say. He likely
heard the crunching of the truck as it crushed the rear of his car,
pushing it forward. The black bumper of Jeffrey Glorioso's pickup
shattered the car's rear window and continued straight through its
passenger cabin.
While authorities could not prove Glorioso was intoxicated that
night, there is no denying that his raised truck had been transformed
into a lethal weapon. As Franco and his four passengers lay bleeding
under Glorioso's 34-inch tires, Glorioso opened the door of his
1995 lifted Dodge Ram truck, jumped into a friend's passing car
and fled the scene.
Three of the five occupants of the Ford died, including Franco.
Glorioso was later arrested at a bar where he had continued partying.
After a plea bargain, he is currently serving a 15-year sentence.
While the Franco accident gives dramatic representation of just
how lethal lifted trucks can be, they appear to be a growing threat.
Detective Paul Thompson, an accident re-constructionist with the
Scottsdale Police Department, says Glorioso's raised suspension
contributed to the severity of the wreck.
"The dynamics of that collision would have been completely different,"
Thompson says. "I can't say there would not have been any fatalities,
but it would have been a different collision."
Despite the deadly potential raised and customized 4x4s possess
in even slow-moving collisions, their popularity seems to be growing
among Valley drivers. Experts say the Valley's highways will be
home to another 2.1 million vehicles by 2025.
The Wild West
In New Jersey, tire sizes are restricted and can be no more than
six inches larger than factory-issue tires. Extreme truck lifts
are subjected to handling stability testing.
Like New Jersey, many states regulate the bumper height of street
legal vehicles. Federal law limits only the weight of personal vehicles-not
the height or tire size.
In Arizona, the sky literally is the limit for modified trucks.
Like several other Western states, Arizona only requires mud flaps
and, if necessary, lower placement of headlights at 54 inches, but
does not require lowered bumpers.
Is it time that the Valley's prairie-day laws catch up with its
metro-crowded population and its status as the nation's fifth largest
city?
Pete Dufrenses thinks not.
Standing next to his chromed and customized 2003 Ford F350, Dufrenses
says America is all about the individual right to express oneself,
through word or through vehicle. His truck, standing nearly 10 feet
high, is wrapped with painted American flags.
"It's a tribute to the 9/11 heroes," Dufrenses says, pointing to
the twin towers on his tailgate, almost a foot above his head. Dufrenses
says he drives his show-winning truck carefully and has never had
a close call. He says his truck's upgraded brakes and video cameras
demonstrate his concern for other motorists.
The Threat
While some high profile vehicle drivers go out of their way to be
considerate, top-heavy SUV's weaving in and out of traffic are a
fairly common sight on crowded Valley roadways. The increased tendency
for these vehicles to roll makes them even more dangerous.
"I can tell you, being a re-constructionist, the higher the center
of gravity, the more likely to roll over," Detective Thompson said.
The American Association of Motor Vehicle Administrators agrees,
reporting that lifted trucks are unstable, take longer to brake
and are more likely to roll.
"They certainly do take longer to brake," said Erin Drake, whose
2003 Ford F350 stands almost nine feet high. "You just need to be
paying attention. I would highly recommend that guys put bigger
brakes on them. The bigger they are, the harder they are to stop."
Because lifted vehicles take longer to stop, they are more likely
to run red lights or rear-end other vehicles when traffic backs
up. As in the Glorioso triple fatality, these fender-benders can
become deadly when vehicles with raised bumpers are involved.
Bumping Heads
The average bumper height of a typical sedan is approximately 20
inches lower than the bumper of a moderately lifted truck.
Sitting in a mid-sized sedan, an average driver's head sits almost
perfectly at eye level with the bumper of a moderately lifted truck.
Law enforcement officials say this is just one reason for limiting
their height.
"It is a public safety concern that bumpers don't have a uniform
height," said Lt. Joe Ruet of the Gilbert Police.
Ruet added that passenger cars are becoming increasingly safer but
that raised bumpers negate many of those advances. "With sidebar
reinforcement, airbags and baby seats, we've had accidents where
two cars were totaled but the mothers walked away with their babies,"
Ruet said. "If that same collision were to occur with a high bumper,
that wouldn't be the case."
Frank Valenzuela, a spokesman for the Arizona Department of Public
Safety, added, "On those extreme-lifted vehicles the biggest concern
our troopers have is when they get in accidents. They can easily
crawl up on other vehicles, and that bumper height is level with
a lot of windows."
Safety Concerns
Despite the obvious dangers of these trucks, several owners justify
raising the height, calling it their right and claiming it's a dangerous
few giving the trucks a bad name. "You'll see kids who just have
something hodge-podge. That's what's getting people hurt," says
Drake, standing proudly next to his nine-foot truck. "If you're
going to drive a big, lifted truck, then cover all the safety issues.
Don't spoil it for everybody else."
Crashes involving modified-vehicles are 29 times more likely to
result in fatalities, according to a Virginia police study recently
cited in U.S. News & World Report. Even Drake cautions, "You have
to have a competent driver in there so you don't hurt anybody."
Yvette Lopez, a spokeswoman for AAA of Arizona, said the national
insurance company does consider raised trucks a greater threat to
motorists. "When you raise your truck it is considered a higher
risk for a rollover," Lopez said. "We do consider raised trucks
to be a lot more dangerous. They can be a lot harder to control."
Regulating Rides
Many Valley residents have yet to consider the threat posed by higher
than average bumpers. Others remain convinced the trucks are lethal
and wonder if it will take more dramatic tragedies to gain the attention
of lawmakers.
A Department of Public Safety spokesperson said the DPS does not
yet consider the trucks a major threat. But Elisabeth, Andrez Franco's
21-year-old sister, does. She believes the law should better protect
drivers like her now deceased brother. "I think there should be
a law that protects the drivers," she says. "It's not fair when
somebody's driving safe, and there's someone who's not driving carefully
(who causes an accident)."
What do you think? Should the law prevent owners from raising their trucks to dangerous levels? Should there be a standard height that cannot be exceeded? Let us know what you think by calling our Sound Off line at 480-391-6519.
|